I don't think it's necessary to pick at each other's code. It's not a competition. Obviously, the best code, 'cleanest' and so on is preferred but if you have a suggestion to someone who is helping about how they could improve then, in general, it would be better to PM the person. I believe FibreOptics opted to do this and tsoglanos started again.
This "check what you said before you post again" attitude is not necessary and it's rude. I think getting rude with each other is going to start an argument and is not productive to this thread! Picking at forum signatures is even less so and completely unnecessary.