I understand your point about the edits, it's indeed probably annoying, but what's the purpose of an edit feature?
To conclude this discussion, when someone tells me "sure you could.... but good luck with ..." that basically means: "yes, you could use that, but it still stinks as a solution". That's not just my interpretation, that's a quite common way of saying something stinks. And I don't like being said my code sucks when I take the time to try to help another person, with no benefit for my own really.
<Timmy> I still haven't rented a Halloween suit.
<Jon> Don't worry about it, just pick one up the night before Halloween.
<Sat> Sure you could do that, but good luck finding anything decent right before Halloween.
Sat means: your proposal sucks, buddy.