Okay. I'm kind of new to this, so I'm all over the place, aren't I?

Anyways, I took your suggestion and made a few modifications to it. I don't exactly know why I was checking if they were on either, but...

Code:
on 1:JOIN:#channelname:{
  if ($nick !isnotify) {
    echo This toon has already recieved this message.
  }
  else {
    notice $nick ...
  }
}


I changed the %s to $s, because I'm looking for them, not the variable (I think.) I also want it to echo IF they are on my notify list, not if they are not on my notify list.

Now, no matter if they are on my notify list or not, it will keep echoing the same message, "This toon has already recieved this message."

It will not go to else and notice the nick the message I put in there.