You are right but what I think he means is the usual gutter level replies like "It sucks" then no reason given as to why the idea might be bad. Posts like that are just wasteful even if perfectly within the rules. When I give an idea I don't mind some contructive criticism or even some flack but there are simpltons out there who just object to everything they don't have the talent or resources to suggest or develop and their reply is always "It sucks" and nothing more. I think most here will object to it to at least some degree. I'm not saying that forums shouldn't remain an open dialogue for ideas, but anyone who replies with "it sucks" or "I don't like it" or "get a life" etc providing no supporting debate as to why they are against a proposal will get bagloads of stick from me.
My two bob's worth...
