As far as I can tell, Autoget of a file from trusted nicks only works when the relevant trust entry is the first in the trust list (which is shown alphabetically). If it is the only entry or if there are entries after it in the list, then autoget works fine.

To recreate:

1. Set Autoget for trusted users and show dialog for untrusted users.
2. Add a single entry for sending nick and have the file sent. It should auto accept.
3. Add a second entry "zzzzzz" which should appear below the above entry. Have the file sent again. It should auto accept.
4. Add a fourth entry "aaaaa" which should appear above the first nick. Have the file sent again. The file accept/ignore/cancel dialog will be shown.