So It seems to be only writing down one of the ini's specifically the last
Code:
  else {
    writeini -n BanList.ini #Michaelukz $2 Banned
    writeini -n BanList.ini #Michaelukz $2 Reason $4
    writeini -n BanList.ini #Michaelukz $2 TimeBannedFor $3
    writeini -n BanList.ini #Michaelukz $2 BannedAt $time
    msg $chan /me User has been banned!
  }
}


Output: derrick=BannedAt 23:37:34