Well I just tested it with that and they both went to the correct windows. I did have to change "badtext" to 0 so that it wouldn't halt.
Are you sure you don't have a similar script loaded and interfering? Insert debug print statements to make sure you're at the lines you think you are. If you can, provide a single test alias like I did before to reliably demonstrate the problem.
I've found the problem - within the entire text there is a URL which has numbers in it. While they don't have a period, they're setting it off.
!Name Title ($0.02) does nothing
!Name Title ($0.02)
https://www.website.com/page.html?Id=3X19M43Z4VULD73G1I2N3GGRYF10D8 sets it off.
Is there a way to force the script to only go off on a number which has a decimal in it?
